In the corporate world, much emphasis is placed on group thinking, problem solving, and collaboration.  Yes, these strategies promote creative thinking in the form of bouncing ideas back and forth between colleagues.  A premature thought may be enhanced by a fellow employee – and the collaboration between the two can lead to an innovative concept that could not have been developed alone.  

However, whatever happened to thinking on one's own?  Being given the privacy and freedom to develop thoughts and ideas in an uninterrupted space?  It's called solitude.  

The question is – what fosters GREATER creative thinking – teamwork or solitude?  

There are two sides of that argument.

According to Susan Cain, author of “Quiet: The Power of Introverts in a World that Can't Stop Talking,” – research shows that performance weakens as the group gets larger.  One of the primary reasons why large numbers generate weaker performance is the clash between personalities.  Louder individuals often talk more – even if their ideas are futile - thereby taking up precious time and energy from the group. On the flipside, solid ideas from introverted employees are left unheard.

Team collaboration does have its positive qualities in that it creates a sense of camaraderie and works as a “social glue” to bring employees together.  However, we must not lose sight of the importance of fostering independent thinking – and giving employees time and space alone to solve problems.  The most creative insights were developed through – yes - solitude. 

It is the job of the decision makers and managers to get creative and bridge the gap between teamwork and solitude.  Online discussion forums are a great solution to this debate because it is a communal forum in which collaboration and teamwork is practiced, but it allows individuals to independently respond and provide input.   

Any other ideas?  Please share your thoughts.